I recently was checking out ChatGPT and the authenticity of the information it produced. Being a teacher in the field I was curious. I did have a conversation with ChatGPT on naming of compounds in chemistry. I have pasted the conversation I had with it and some conflicts I had with the AI’s response. Overall the rules it gave me was accurate however there was a conflict in a rule it stated and the example it gave which contradicted. Here is the conversation posted with no alteration
Naming of Compounds: What are the rules necessary to name ionic compounds and molecular compounds?
Ionic compounds are compounds composed of ions, which are atoms or molecules that have a net electric charge. To name ionic compounds, the cation (positive ion) is named first, followed by the anion (negative ion). The cation is named using the element’s name, and the anion is named by taking the element’s name and adding the suffix -ide. For example, the compound NaCl is named sodium chloride, with sodium being the cation and chloride being the anion.
Molecular compounds are compounds composed of molecules, which are groups of atoms held together by chemical bonds. To name molecular compounds, prefixes are used to indicate the number of atoms of each element present in the compound. The prefixes are: mono- (1), di- (2), tri- (3), tetra- (4), penta- (5), hexa- (6), hepta- (7), octa- (8), nona- (9), and deca- (10). The element present in the largest amount is written first, followed by the element present in the second largest amount. The prefixes are used to indicate the number of atoms of each element present in the compound. For example, H2O is named water, CO2 is named carbon dioxide
In molecular compounds do you write the name of the element in more quantity and the element present less as the second element? Can you clarify.
Yes, that is correct. In molecular compounds, the element present in the greatest quantity is written first, followed by the element present in the second greatest quantity. The prefixes are used to indicate the number of atoms of each element present in the compound. For example, in the molecular compound CO2, carbon is present in greater quantity than oxygen, so it is written first, followed by oxygen. The prefix “di” is used to indicate that there are two oxygen atoms, so the compound is named “carbon dioxide.”
It’s worth noting that when the compound has only two elements, the prefix is not used. For example, H2O is water, instead of Dihydrogen monoxide. Also when the prefixes are used, the ending of the second element is changed to -ide. This is the case for example in P4O10, which is named tetraphosphorus decoxide instead of tetraphosphorus oxide.
I don’t believe the statement is true as you have contradicted yourself with the example of P2O5.
I apologize for the confusion, you are correct that my previous statement is not accurate. The ending of the second element is not always changed to -ide. In the case of P4O10, it is named tetraphosphorus decoxide instead of tetraphosphorus oxide. Similarly, P2O5 is named diphosphorus pentoxide.
In general, when naming molecular compounds, the element present in the greatest quantity is written first, followed by the element present in the second greatest quantity, with prefixes indicating the number of atoms of each element present in the compound. However, there are some exceptions to this rule and the ending of the second element is not always changed to -ide.
I apologize for any confusion that my previous answer may have caused. Thank you for bringing this to my attention.
I believe the correct answer to my first question is the element that is written first is more electro positive than the second element. Do you think this statement is right?
No, that statement is not correct. The naming rule for molecular compounds is that the element present in the greatest quantity is written first, followed by the element present in the second greatest quantity, with prefixes indicating the number of atoms of each element present in the compound. The electronegativity of the elements is not taken into consideration when naming molecular compounds.
In contrast, the naming rule for ionic compounds is that the cation (positive ion) is named first, followed by the anion (negative ion). Cations are formed by the loss of electrons from atoms, and the number of electrons lost determines the charge on the cation. Anions are formed by the gain of electrons to atoms, and the number of electrons gained determines the charge on the anion. Ionic compounds are neutral compounds composed of cations and anions and their formula is determined by the charges on the ions.
I apologize for any confusion that my previous answers may have caused. Thank you for bringing this to my attention.
I am talking about molecular compounds. In P2O5 The element written first P you have two of them and O the second element you have five. I see that you have contradicted your first statement with the example (P2O5) you cited.
I apologize for any confusion, you are correct that my previous statement regarding the naming of molecular compounds was not entirely accurate. The element written first is not always the element present in greater quantity.
In the case of P2O5, the element phosphorus (P) is written first, even though it is present in lesser quantity than oxygen (O). This is because the naming conventions for molecular compounds are based on the traditional (stock) nomenclature system, which prioritizes naming the element that is more electropositive first, as you mentioned, before giving the number of atoms present in the compound.
Therefore, in P2O5, phosphorus is written first, followed by oxygen, with the prefix “di” indicating that there are two phosphorus atoms and “penta” indicating that there are five oxygen atoms, so the compound is named “diphosphorus pentoxide.”
I apologize for any confusion caused by my previous answers and for not being more clear and precise in my first response.
Take suggestions from ChatGPT with caution, validate and confirm the information.